Butter and Pound Cakes Explained

by Debra Wyatt
(last updated March 9, 2020)

3

It is easy to see why most people confuse butter and pound cakes. There are many similarities between the two cakes. However similar they are, there are differences between the two types of cakes.

Butter cakes and pound cakes are some of the more popular cakes in America. It has been the thought that the butter cake actually evolved from the pound cake; they do have a lot in common. Both the pound cake and the American butter cakes have a rich buttery taste, along with having fine crumbs. The two types of cakes also have a texture that is moist and tender. However, there is a difference between the two.

The butter cake (also known as a shortened cake or as a creamed cake) is an American classic. This cake has a richer taste than most of all the other cakes, except for the pound cake, and it does have a better volume than that of other cakes and is lighter in texture. While the pound cake has the richest flavor of all the cakes, it is also the denser of the two types of cakes.

One of the biggest differences between the two cakes is that originally the pound cake was made with a pound of each of its main ingredients. That would be a pound of flour, butter, eggs, and sugar with an addition of some type of leavening added (either baking powder or baking soda). Then a flavoring like vanilla or lemon is added to the recipe. Often times the quantity needs to be changed so that it can fit to the size of cake that is wanted. If the ratio of 1:1:1:1 of flour, butter, eggs, and sugar is maintained then it is considered to be a pound cake, even if smaller quantities are used.

The pound cake is a very versatile cake. It can be served plain or fancy; it still has a great taste. I have seen pound cakes served in a bowl with fruit as it's topping, as well as a base that is covered with a fondant.

While both butter and pound cakes are delicious, the butter cake is defiantly America's favorite. The flavor combinations that can be made from a butter cake are literally limitless. This is the cake that seems to appear most often at celebrations all decorated with frosting for whatever celebration that is going on. It is a good cake to serve at almost any occasion.

Author Bio

Debra Wyatt

Deb has a communications degree and applies her talents to her position as Marketing Specialist at Sharon Parq Associates. In her spare time she spends time with her children and grandchildren and devotes time to her church. ...

MORE FROM DEBRA

Declutter Your Bedroom

Has your bedroom exploded with stuff, leaving behind a cluttered mess? The ideas in this tip will help you handle the ...

Discover More

Organizing Small Kitchen Appliances

Small kitchen appliances don't have to take over your kitchen. With a little bit of organizing and creativity you can ...

Discover More

Planting Tomatoes

Do you want to grow some tomatoes, but are not sure what to do? Here are some easy tips that you can use to help grow ...

Discover More
More Cooking Tips

Frosting a Cake

Frosting a cake presents a unique quandary in cooking. It is both one of the easies things, and one of the most difficult ...

Discover More

Baking Cakes

How can you really tell if your cake is done when the timer goes off? And what do you do if it won't come out of the pan? ...

Discover More

Old Fashioned Banana Cake

There are several cakes out there for you to make; however, those cakes can sometimes get kind of old. Here is a great ...

Discover More
Subscribe

FREE SERVICE: Receive an e-mail several times each week with a featured cooking tip. Enter your address and click "Subscribe."

Comments

If you would like to add an image to your comment (not an avatar, but an image to help in making the point of your comment), include the characters [{fig}] (all 7 characters, in the sequence shown) in your comment text. You’ll be prompted to upload your image when you submit the comment. Maximum image size is 6Mpixels. Images larger than 600px wide or 1000px tall will be reduced. Up to three images may be included in a comment. All images are subject to review. Commenting privileges may be curtailed if inappropriate images are posted.

What is five minus 3?

2021-03-09 04:05:35

Anthony

The difference between pound cake and butter, or "sponge cake" is simple.

Pound cake: crack your eggs, then weigh them, then use one-to-one butter sugar flour.

Sponge cake or butter cake: weighyour eggs before you crack them. Then use that weight for your flour sugar and butter


2020-07-24 18:20:41

Noone Nobody

This article purports to explain the difference between a pound cake and a butter cake, explains what a pound cake is but never explains how a butter cake is different.


2020-06-03 12:51:55

Grace

I prefer butter loaf cake toasted, rather than regular loaf cake especially Entenmann's. (see Figure 1 below)

Figure 1. Entenmanns cake ( butter)


Subscribe

FREE SERVICE: Receive an e-mail several times each week with a featured cooking tip. Enter your address and click "Subscribe."

(Your e-mail address is not shared with anyone, ever.)